Michelle Williams

Anna Watson

Meat Loaf

Billy

Tim Guinee

Tom

Louis Zorich

Sammy

Bill Raymond

Dr. Harold Ashton

Wendell Pierce

Dan

Merritt Wever

Betty

Jonathan Watton

Bobby Watson

Ileen Getz

Nurse Aphrodite

John Paul Tremblay

Moe

Robb Wells

Joe

Heidi von Palleske

Cindy Watson

Jeremy Akerman

Robert Watson Sr.

Gerry Mendicino

Johnnie

John Dunsworth

Pastor

Paul Macleod

Preacher

Meaghan Hutchison

Dopnna Frankel

Rhonda McLean

Jane Frankel

Bruce Graham

Frank Frankel

Gary Levert

Mental Health Visitor

Dennis Brown

Herman

Mark A. Owen

Bartender

Shaun Clarke

Tony the Toastmaster

Mike Smith

Lobotomy Patient

Mark Day

Mark (uncredited)

Marcus Shultz

Bartender #2 (uncredited)