Caitlin Custer

The Babysitter

Ben Hethcoat

The Killer

Alison Gallaher

Mrs. Debra Kubler

Mike C. Nelson

Dr. Harold Kubler

Bradley Bundlie

Logan Kubler

DeMorge Brown

Don Weaver

Trian Long Smith

Nora Waters

Joe Hartzler

Deputy Wilkes

Barak Hardley

Deputy Barns

Robert Craighead

Detective Lou Mass

Sam Eidson

The Slasher

Kayli Hernandez

Sally

Kirk C. Johnson

Kirk

Josephine McAdam

Faye

Katie Folger

Kirk's Girlfriend